These are very niceSharonI purchased two and they are perfect. Very sturdy and easy to put together. Happy I got them, they look very nice 5
No the sameAnonymous reviewerI noticed two different Billy bookcases and one was not in stock for white. So I ordered the new version. The quality is somewhat lacking. The back board is not as thick as in the older model and it has some type of tape to reinforce the creases for the backing. The creases are noticeable when assembled. It has texture to it too, not smooth like older model. When assembled its flimsy somehow, not sure if its because the backing is not as supportive as old version. Also, when sliding the backing in place it caves in allot. I also did not like the plastic nails things. I prefer the older version but its too much of a hassle to return. I'll probably cover the backing with some peel and stick wall paper and add some 1x2s to the back for extra support. I would defiantly not recommend the new version and hopefully they bring back the old version of the Billy. That one was perfect.2
Bully book case ElaineIt's a great product. 5
Shelf falls apartGrantThis shelf was awful! Within maybe a month of owning it, it completely collapsed. The shelves are held up with little knobs, meaning the stability of the shelf is entirely reliant on the main frame staying together. Unfortunately, the main frame did not like to stay together! As the main frame would expand, the shelves would fall. The first time this happened, I was able to put the frame back together and make the bookshelf last for a few more months (and paid extra, laser focused, careful attention to assembly this time). But the other day, the middle shelf completely collapsed - mind you, this shelf holding 6 watches, two perfume bottles, and some jewelry. In total, I had this shelf for 7 months before tossing it to the curb. Incredibly disappointed in this produced, and I recommend spending just a bit more on a bookshelf that is put together with proper screws holding the shelves in place.1
Probably have too many Billy bookcasesLisaAffordable and does the job. Not fancy but will hold up after many years.4
Bookcase works!JuneNice bookcase. Screws bleed through the wood when tightened. Shelving is held in place with a peg. Be careful the shelf can shift and land your items / books in the shelf below. I put mine inside of an empty closet in my home office. I also keep my printer and a small file cabinet in there. 4
Cheap plastic screwsSeanThe wood seems fine, but they use cheap plastic screws for the main assembly. These screws snap so easily it makes me feel like this thing is not gonna last long at all. And there are not extra parts in the bag so if one breaks you will need to call them or visit the store again to get more parts. I'm really surprised that they'd skimp out on using real metal for such small pieces.2
Billy bookcaseAllisonGood quality but a-bit hard to put together. But I finally figured it out.very sturdy and beautiful piece of work. 5
Budget friendlyLeeannThis works perfectly for a teenagers room! 4
Barely a bookcaseMaliaI see why its going out of the website. They changes make the thing unable to function as its too flimsy, weak and unable to function1
Billy Bookcase Item #00477337 4x DefectiveIraDEFECTIVE from manufacturer 4X in 2 weeks: Please do not purchase this item. I tried 4 Billy bookcases ordered 2 at a time 2 weeks apart, ostensibly from 2 different IKEA warehouses and BOTH shipments totaling 4 Billy bookcases had this exact same issue: The side panel grooves that guide the entire backing panel are not cut evenly, nor are they cut lengthwise equally, therefore making the entire unit almost impossible to build and entirely impossible to trust it's stability at all.
+3 hours on the phone with 3 different customer service agents with conflicting answers to my question of where my Billy's were shipped from while only all agreeing on the negative when asked if they would escalate this to a supervisor ("No") as there are no such entities according to IKEA customer "service"), could anyone look at the units before they shipped? ("NO")
However, a resounding YES to accumulated lost time in my now stagnated project the Billy's were intended to finish. NOW: IKEA & I are DONE1
Short bookcaseLorrainePerfect for our need. Looks nice and holds all necessary items. 5
Every home needs a bookcase or two or moreLindaLove it!5
Billy - our favoriteJanetEasy to assemble. various colors. not as good quality when it first came out, but still very good.5
Birch effect different Anonymous reviewerI have Billy bookcases in the birch veneer from more than ten years ago. When I purchased a new piece in the birch effect this year it clearly didn’t match. The new birch is whiter and cooler toned than the old one. Kinda disappointing the new piece won’t match the old ones. I also agree with other reviews that the shelves are not wide enough so they don’t fit flush against the outer frame. 3
Great shelfCarolineNice shelf, taller than other ones like it, easy to put together and looks great next to our taller Billy cabinet with glass doors. Great value and holds a lot of books. 5
GOOD AGAINRodneyI purchased & assembled 30+ IKEA, Billy, glass door, shelf units over the decade. I will buy more in the future. I am quite satisfied with these units.5
Sturdy and Functional CarolynI love the sleek design. It’s simple and functional. This bookshelf is sturdy enough to hold all my heavy books and put a few decorative touches on the top.5
Happy with my purchaseEmilyI’m happy with it for the price 5
Billy bookcases FriedaEasy to assemble, great storage solution. 5